Guilty By Definition by Susie Dent 

Yes, THAT Susie Dent.  The personification of an academic crush and author of several great books on the meaning of words. Sadly, this is hung too heavily on that framework and doesn’t have enough verve or warmth to fit onto the increasingly overloaded bookshelves of cosy crime.  

Martha is a lexicographer working in Oxford.  She begins to receive postcards, referencing literature and words about her sister Charlotte, who disappeared over a decade ago.  That, in itself is a pretty familiar concept.  Plus, most books feature a protagonist who is based on its author - Martha, with her work for ‘Clarendon English Dictionary’ and appearances on TV is no exception.  

The real problem with this novel is the use of definition, in its literal sense.  Barely a page goes by without the meaning of an obscure word, even the chapter titles themselves.  It’s an amiable enough read, and Martha and her Scooby Gang of word lovers will probably return. But it’s not dynamic enough as a crime novel, nor is it learned enough to be an almanac.  

It’s a ‘copacetic’ read, but not a ‘meritorious’ one.  It’s published by Bonnier Books on 15th August and I thank them for a preview copy.  #guiltybydefinition